# Must Money Be Tangible in Islam? What the Qur'an, Sunnah and Classical Scholars Actually Establish

> If money must be gold, silver or another physical commodity, are bank balances and digital payments impermissible? This article looks at what the Qur'an, the Sunnah and classical scholars actually say.

By M Azim Abdul Majeed · Published 2026-09-04 · Source: https://azim.cc/blog/must-money-be-tangible-in-islam

## Key takeaways

- The Prophet ﷺ used the gold and silver coins already in circulation and did not issue a new currency. He gave rules for trade, debts and riba. The first fully Islamic coins came later, under Abd al-Malik in 77 AH.
- The hadith of the six commodities tells us how certain things may be exchanged. It also names wheat, barley, dates and salt, so it is not a list of what money must be.
- Imam Malik said that if people adopted skins as currency, he would dislike selling them for gold and silver on deferred terms. Ibn Taymiyyah wrote that the dirham and dinar have no natural or legal definition and go back to custom.
- Saudi Arabia's Council of Senior Scholars decided by majority that money is whatever people generally accept as a medium of exchange. The International Islamic Fiqh Academy accepts a credit to a bank account as valid possession.
- Being intangible does not make money impermissible, and it does not make money sound. We still have to ask how money is created, who bears its risks, and whether it protects people's wealth.

If money must be gold, silver or another physical commodity, does that make modern bank balances and digital payments impermissible?

This is not only a theoretical question. According to the Saudi Central Bank, electronic payments made up 79% of retail payments in Saudi Arabia in 2024. So if Islam requires money to be physical, most everyday purchases in the Kingdom would be in doubt.

Throughout history, people have used many different things as money. Gold, silver, copper coins, paper currency, bank deposits and digital payment systems have all done this job.

So what does Islam actually require? Does it require money to be a tangible commodity, or does it give us principles for whatever society adopts as money?

I have looked at the Qur'an, the Sunnah and the classical scholars on this question. I found clear rules on how wealth may change hands and how people must be treated, but I did not find a text that fixes the material money must be made of. To see why, we have to separate what people used during the lifetime of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ from what Allah and His Messenger made obligatory.

## The Prophet ﷺ Used Existing Money

During the Prophet's lifetime, people in Arabia used gold and silver coins from the Byzantine and Persian monetary systems.

He ﷺ did not create a new currency. He did not ask people to replace their coins with a special Islamic coin. The historian al-Maqrizi later recorded that he accepted the dinar and dirham already in use. The first fully Islamic dinars were struck much later, under the caliph Abd al-Malik in 77 AH.

What he gave people were rules on trade, money exchange, debts and riba.

Now consider today's Saudi riyal. A SAR 500 note does not contain SAR 500 worth of paper. Its value comes from the country's monetary arrangements, what it can buy, public acceptance and a fixed exchange rate of 3.75 riyals to the US dollar since 1986.

A balance of SAR 500 in a bank account is not a particular set of notes kept in a drawer. It is a financial claim, and people use it every day to buy goods and settle what they owe.

This leads to the main question. Must the money itself be a commodity, or must it reliably represent purchasing power and legitimate rights?

Gold and silver give us a historical precedent. That alone does not show that their physical material is a permanent religious requirement.

## Does Qur'an 4:29 Require Money to Be a Commodity?

Allah says:

> "O you who have believed, do not consume one another's wealth unjustly but only [in lawful] business by mutual consent." (An-Nisa 4:29)

Imam al-Tabari explains in *Jami' al-Bayan* that this means you must not take one another's property through what Allah has forbidden, and he gives riba and gambling as examples. He also reports that scholars differed on the meaning of mutual consent. His own preference is that a sale is complete when the two parties separate after consenting, having had the option to cancel.

The ayah makes lawful trade by mutual agreement legitimate. It does not say that payment must be made in gold, silver or another physical commodity.

Consider a farmer in Al-Qassim who sells 100 kilograms of dates to a restaurant in Riyadh for SAR 2,500.

The restaurant may pay with notes, by bank transfer or through an agreed digital payment. In each case, the farmer supplies real dates and receives something accepted as payment. The dates are the same and the trade is the same. Only the payment method changes, along with the obligations that come with it.

The Islamic questions are about genuine consent, lawful ownership, certainty of payment, the absence of deception and freedom from anything prohibited.

Of course, consent alone cannot make a prohibited transaction lawful. Two people agreeing to riba does not make riba permissible, because "Allah has permitted trade and has forbidden interest" (Al-Baqarah 2:275).

**The point is that Qur'an 4:29 sets conditions for lawful exchange. It does not list the materials from which money must be made.**

## The Six Commodities: Rules of Exchange

The Prophet ﷺ said:

> "Gold is to be paid for by gold, silver by silver, wheat by wheat, barley by barley, dates by dates, and salt by salt, like for like and equal for equal, payment being made hand to hand." (Sahih Muslim 1587c)

This hadith is often used in discussions about Islamic money.

But look at how it works in practice. If two farmers exchange a measure of dates for an equal measure of dates, this hadith applies to them. Yet neither of them is using dates as the community's currency.

The hadith names two monetary metals and four foods. It regulates certain exchanges, and it does not say that all six must be money. The same narration goes on to allow exchange between different classes, as long as it is hand to hand.

This hadith also directly governs money. When gold is exchanged for gold, or gold for silver, its rules protect against riba. So it is not only about barter.

Classical jurists extended these rules to other items, and they differed on the underlying legal cause (*'illah*). Shafi'i jurists linked gold and silver to their use as prices. Hanafi jurists linked them to weight and measure.

There is another hadith that helps here. When people were exchanging mixed dates for better dates at unequal amounts, the Prophet ﷺ told them to sell the mixed dates for money and then buy the good dates with that money (Sahih al-Bukhari 2201). In my reading, the money in this hadith is doing a job: it lets both lots of dates be priced fairly.

We must therefore separate **a ruling on how certain things may be exchanged from a ruling on what alone may serve as money.**

## Classical Scholars Recognised Money Beyond Precious Metals

Imam Malik (d. 179 AH) discussed this in the *Mudawwanah*, in the Book of Currency Exchange. He said:

> "If people were to accept skins among themselves until they had coinage and currency status, I would dislike their being sold for gold and silver on deferred terms."

The translation is mine.

Why is this significant? Animal skin is not gold or silver, yet Imam Malik considered that it could be used as money, and that the rules of monetary exchange would then apply to it. This was a hypothetical case and he expressed dislike, not a formal prohibition. He was also not approving every privately issued currency. But it shows that the discussion was not limited to gold and silver.

Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 728 AH) wrote:

> "As for the dirham and the dinar, no natural or legal definition is known for them. Rather, their reference is to custom and convention." (*Majmu' al-Fatawa* 19:251, my translation)

He adds that dirhams and dinars are not wanted for themselves. They are a means of dealing with one another, and a standard for those dealings.

I should be fair about the context. Ibn Taymiyyah was discussing the amounts of dirhams and dinars and the measures used in Shariah. He was not ruling on money made from other materials, so applying his words to paper or digital money is a further step.

But the senior scholars of Saudi Arabia took that step themselves.

When the Council of Senior Scholars studied paper money in 1393 AH (1973), it asked the Governor of the Saudi monetary agency whether the riyal was covered by silver, or whether the name only preserved an old label. In its Decision No. 10, the Council said that money is anything treated as money by custom or convention, so that people generally accept it as a medium of exchange. It quoted Ibn Taymiyyah's words to support this. It ruled that paper money is currency in its own right, and that each paper currency is a separate kind, so the Saudi riyal is one and the US dollar is another.

In 1986, the International Islamic Fiqh Academy also ruled that paper currencies are "a legal form of money", subject to the rulings of gold and silver on riba, zakat and salam (Resolution 21 (9/3)).

The Saudi decision was by majority, so not every member agreed. There is also an older concern that deserves respect. Al-Maqrizi, writing in Egypt during years of famine, blamed copper coinage for harming people and wanted a return to gold and silver. As I read him, his complaint is mostly about debasement and who paid for it, which is a complaint about how the monetary system was run.

Some readers will say that fiat money should not count in this argument at all, because its own legitimacy is in question. That is a serious objection. It deserves its own article, so I treat it as a different discussion. The question here is narrower: does Islam require money to be tangible? Imam Malik's example and Ibn Taymiyyah's words do not depend on fiat money being sound.

## A Bank Credit Can Count as Possession

When money is exchanged for money, possession must be immediate. If possession meant holding something physical, a bank transfer could never satisfy this rule.

The International Islamic Fiqh Academy addressed this in Jeddah in March 1990 (Resolution 53 (4/6)). It accepted constructive possession, which means possession without physically holding the item. One of the forms it listed is a sum of money credited to a customer's bank account, including when a bank moves money from one account to another on the customer's order. Banks must follow the Shariah rules of currency exchange, and the crediting must not take longer than usual.

Suppose a merchant in Jeddah receives SAR 10,000 by bank transfer and uses it to buy supplies. No gold, silver or notes pass between the parties. Under this resolution, the merchant has still taken possession.

This resolution does not approve everything banks do. It does not address how the deposit was created either. It only answers the claim that possession must be physical.

## Money Is Not the Wealth It Measures

Suppose a carpenter in Jeddah makes a table worth SAR 5,000 and sells it.

The table is the result of his labour and skill, the timber, the machinery and his time. Money lets him exchange the value of that work for other goods and services.

Now suppose he is paid by bank transfer. The table was still made, the carpenter still did the work, and he still received a recognised financial claim.

But an important distinction remains.

**Money being useful for exchange does not prove that the system creating and managing it is sound.**

If monetary authorities or banks expand money and credit too much, the resulting inflation can take purchasing power away from people who already hold that money. The carpenter's SAR 5,000 would then buy less, through no fault of his.

A digital instrument can also make payments efficient and still be too volatile for ordinary trade. I have written separately that [Bitcoin is not halal as a product or monetary medium](/blog/bitcoin-ethereum-and-xrp). That view does not rest on Bitcoin being intangible. It rests on problems such as its volatility, the loss of inheritance when keys are lost and the energy cost of Proof-of-Work.

Neither the physical existence of gold nor the digital existence of a balance is enough to decide whether a monetary system is just or reliable.

## The Real Question: What Happens to People's Wealth?

Allah says:

> "And do not deprive people of their due." (Ash-Shu'ara 26:183)

He also commands:

> "And give full measure and weight in justice." (Al-An'am 6:152)

These ayat establish fairness and justice in economic dealings, and they apply to physical money as well as anything else.

Consider two monetary systems. The first uses physical commodities but allows people to manipulate their purity, weight or exchange. The second uses digital accounting units, with transparent issuance, reliable settlement, enforceable ownership and safeguards against arbitrary expansion.

Can we say the first is just because its money is tangible? Can we say the second is unjust because its money is intangible?

I have not found evidence for that conclusion. If someone can show me such a text with its reasoning, I will change my view.

At the same time, a digital currency does not become legitimate only because people accept it voluntarily. Its issuance, ownership, exchange rules, risks and consequences must all be examined.

The preservation of wealth (*hifz al-mal*) is among the objectives of Shariah, which makes these questions important.

I am also aware of the limit of my argument. Custom can make something money, but it is much less clear that custom can make the way that money is issued just. The scholars I have quoted were not asked about central banks or software, so applying their reasoning to our time is my responsibility.

## Money Is a Means

The Qur'an and Sunnah set obligations on lawful exchange, justice, ownership, riba and the protection of people's wealth.

Gold and silver were important in history, and the Prophet ﷺ regulated their exchange. But what people historically used and what Islam made obligatory are not the same thing.

**The decisive question is not whether money can be touched. It is whether the rights and wealth it represents are legitimate, reliable and justly administered.**

---

*This article presents an economic and jurisprudential argument for scholarly examination, not a fatwa, and its proposed criteria are subject to further evaluation against the Qur'an, Sunnah, established jurisprudence, and verifiable economic evidence.*

## References

- Qur'an (Sahih International translation): 2:275; 4:29; 6:152; 26:183.
- Sahih Muslim 1587c, Ubadah ibn al-Samit: the six commodities.
- Sahih al-Bukhari 2201, Abu Sa'id al-Khudri and Abu Hurairah: selling mixed dates for money and buying good dates with it.
- Al-Tabari, [*Jami' al-Bayan*](https://islamweb.net/ar/library/content/50/1234/), commentary on An-Nisa 4:29, vol. 8.
- Malik ibn Anas, [*al-Mudawwanah*](https://www.islamweb.net/ar/library/content/30/3237/), Kitab al-Sarf, on delay in exchanging fulus, vol. 3.
- Ibn Taymiyyah, [*Majmu' al-Fatawa*](https://ar.wikisource.org/wiki/مجموع_الفتاوى/المجلد_التاسع_عشر/فصل_في_مقادير_الدراهم_والدنانير_والمكاييل), vol. 19, pp. 251-252.
- Al-Maqrizi, *Ighathat al-Ummah*, as discussed in [International Journal of Islamic Economics and Finance Studies, 2020/1](https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/1030977).
- ["The Scope of Illah (Causal Effect) of Riba Prohibition on Gold and Silver: A Juristic Analysis"](https://jcis.uitm.edu.my/journal/volume10/issue2/), *Journal of Contemporary Islamic Studies*, vol. 10, no. 2.
- Council of Senior Scholars (Saudi Arabia), [Decision No. 10 on paper currency](https://shamela.ws/book/21759/84), 1393 AH, in *Abhath Hay'at Kibar al-Ulama*, vol. 1.
- International Islamic Fiqh Academy, [Resolution No. 21 (9/3)](https://iifa-aifi.org/en/32270.html), Amman, October 1986.
- International Islamic Fiqh Academy, [Resolution No. 53 (4/6)](https://iifa-aifi.org/en/32405.html), Jeddah, March 1990.
- Saudi Central Bank, ["E-Payments Account for 79% of Total Retail Payments in 2024"](https://www.sama.gov.sa/en-us/mediacenter/news/pages/news-1083.aspx), April 2025.
- Saudi Central Bank statement on the riyal peg at 3.75 to the dollar since 1986, [sama.gov.sa](https://www.sama.gov.sa/en-US/MediaCenter/News/Pages/News20031004.aspx).
