# Bitcoin, Ethereum and XRP: Currency or Speculative Digital Property? - (Is Crypto Halal in Islam Series)

> Bitcoin has fallen by more than half several times, and heirs can lose it forever to a missing key. Part III applies the Currency Litmus Test to Bitcoin, Ether and XRP, and reaches stated verdicts.

By M Azim Abdul Majeed · Published 2026-11-01 · Source: https://azim.cc/blog/bitcoin-ethereum-and-xrp

## Key takeaways

- Bitcoin, Ether and XRP can all be transferred and priced, but neither fact makes them money. The test is whether they independently measure wages, contracts and debts.
- Bitcoin fell about 94% in 2011, about 78% in 2021-2022 and about 54% in 2025-2026. Its protocol kept working throughout, which is why those falls count against it as a monetary measure.
- Classical scholars described money as a measure that should not itself be traded as a commodity for profit. Bitcoin's prevailing use is close to the opposite of that role.
- El Salvador tested Bitcoin as legal tender, and researchers found usage low, concentrated and falling. Its law was amended in 2025 so that merchants no longer have to accept it.
- Bitcoin has no protocol-level recovery when every key is lost, which places a real burden on property and inheritance rights.
- Proof-of-Work must justify its continuing energy cost. A clean energy mix does not answer that, because clean electricity also has other uses.
- My position is that Bitcoin is not halal as a product or monetary medium under present conditions, and that Ether and XRP are not halal as general-purpose currencies. These are personal research judgments, not fatwas, reached instrument by instrument because not all crypto belongs in one category. Contemporary rulings differ on trading, and Malaysia's Shariah Advisory Council and Muhammadiyah's 2026 fatwa permit it within conditions.

*Part III of V. Applying the Currency Litmus Test of Monetary Legitimacy and Islamic Economic Justice*

Bitcoin is not halal as a product or a monetary medium. That is my position, under its present architecture and prevailing economic use.

No suspense, then. In [Part I](/blog/before-we-ask-whether-cryptocurrency-is-halal) I asked what makes something legitimate money. In [Part II](/blog/the-currency-litmus-test) I built a test: monetary origination, distribution, purchasing power, ownership, recoverability, resource use, and fifteen characteristics of sound money. Now the test has to do some work, and a test that never reaches a conclusion is only a way of looking busy.

Bitcoin, Ether and XRP each get their own verdict here, because crypto isn't one category. All can be moved electronically, all have market prices, and all have been presented in some degree as ways of transferring value. Does that make them money?

I don't believe it does, and the evidence below is why.

Before we begin: these are research-based personal judgments, not fatwas, and I'll state the exact scope of each one. I welcome disagreement that brings its own arguments, because that's how a question like this matures, and the criteria apply equally to every instrument, GX Protocol included. Who built it doesn't matter.

## A Price Is Not a Monetary Standard

Wheat has a price. So do salt, shares, houses and paintings, and none of them becomes a currency by being exchangeable.

Money does a different job. A merchant prices stock in it, an employer calculates wages in it, a farmer plans next season's inputs in it, and a household carries purchasing power in it from payday to the next bill. That job raises an awkward question for an asset launched as *a peer-to-peer electronic cash system*.

Where is its independent standard?

An exchange rate alone isn't the problem, since the euro and the yen have dollar exchange rates too. The test is whether the instrument itself measures the obligation. If a computer is priced at USD 1,000 and the buyer sends whatever quantity of Bitcoin equals that amount today, the dollar has done the measuring. Bitcoin has only done the settling.

Paying isn't measuring. I said that in Part II, and most of this article follows from it.

## What the Tradition Actually Asked of Money

Defenders often treat stability as a modern economist's preference. It isn't. The classical scholars described money by its function long before central banks existed, and they described it in terms that should trouble anyone calling Bitcoin digital gold.

Al-Ghazali wrote in the *Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din* that dinars and dirhams were created as judges and mediators between other forms of wealth, and that they were "created to circulate between hands". Ibn Taymiyyah held that the purpose of *athman*, monetary prices, is to be a measure of wealth rather than things sought for themselves. His student Ibn al-Qayyim went further in *I'lam al-Muwaqqi'in*: the price is the standard by which the valuation of wealth is known, so it must be fixed and stable, neither rising nor falling. He condemned the harm that followed when copper coin was taken as a commodity traded for profit.

Read that again. Then think about how Bitcoin is held. People buy it because they expect it to rise, they hold it because it might rise further, and they are told not to spend it. That is a commodity traded for profit, almost to the letter.

I need to be careful here. These scholars were writing about gold, silver and copper coin, not software, and applying them to Bitcoin is my reasoning, not theirs. Ibn al-Qayyim's standard also can't be met perfectly by anything, gold included, as I conceded in Part II, and it cuts hard against fiat as well, which Part IV will have to face. But the direction is plain. Money is meant to measure and to move. An asset whose main attraction is its own appreciation is doing neither.

The Qur'an supplies the wider frame. "O you who have believed, do not consume one another's wealth unjustly but only [in lawful] business by mutual consent" (An-Nisa 4:29; see also Al-Baqarah 2:188). "And give full measure when you measure, and weigh with an even balance" (Al-Isra 17:35). The second verse doesn't require constant purchasing power, and I won't pretend it does, but it gives us the right question: can people rely on the thing they measure with?

## Bitcoin's First Failure: Purchasing Power

Bitcoin's network has largely worked as designed since January 2009. That's a real achievement. It is also a separate question, because a transferable asset can be technically sound and economically unstable at the same time.

Look at what the record shows.

In June 2011 Bitcoin reached about USD 31.91 on Mt Gox. By November it had fallen to around USD 2, a drop of about 94%. A holding worth USD 100,000 at the peak was worth roughly USD 6,300 at the low. The period did include real trouble at Mt Gox, including a June hack that briefly crashed the exchange's price, so it would be wrong to say nothing happened. Still, the supply cap hadn't moved, and the cryptography hadn't failed.

It happened again. From a record near USD 69,000 in November 2021, Bitcoin fell to around USD 15,500 a year later as the FTX collapse spread, a fall of about 78%. Then in October 2025 it set a new record of USD 126,198, and in June 2026 it traded near USD 58,000, about 54% lower. It has recovered part of that since, but recovery is not what a person with a bill due in June needed to hear.

Bitcoin remained Bitcoin throughout. So what changed?

The market's willingness to pay for it, and that's the whole issue.

Take a scenario. An agricultural business sells its produce and receives 10 BTC when one is worth USD 126,000, so USD 1.26 million in dollar terms. It holds them, and the price falls to USD 58,000. Ten BTC is still ten BTC. The business can now buy USD 580,000 worth of fuel, fertiliser and transport. About USD 680,000 of purchasing capacity has gone, and no harvest failed, no machine broke, and no customer defaulted.

Now scale it. Extend that to an economy whose wages, pensions and public contracts rest on the same asset. Households would face sudden cuts in what their savings buy, businesses couldn't plan their inputs, and years of careful saving could shrink inside one season. Nobody should have to become a speculator to protect a salary.

Money is supposed to make exchange easier, not add a market bet to every transaction.

### Three Objections Worth Answering

"One Bitcoin always equals one Bitcoin." True, and one dollar always equals one dollar, which I criticised in Part II as hiding decline, because nominal identity is not stability. If ten BTC buys a tractor today and half a tractor in eight months, the unchanged balance solves nothing.

"Those are just supply and demand." Also true. Markets discover the price of paintings and rare collectibles as well, and explaining why a speculative asset moved doesn't justify using it as a measure.

"The dollar has lost far more over the long run." It has lost a great deal. I won't defend that. But a slow, documented erosion and a 78% fall in a single year are different failures, and neither one acquits the other. If your defence of Bitcoin is that fiat is also bad, you've given a reason to look for something better, and you haven't shown that Bitcoin is it.

There is one more comparison I reject: digital gold. Gold's purchasing power moves too, as I said in Part II, but gold has physical and commercial uses that don't depend on anyone's view of its price. Bitcoin's demand is inseparable from expectations about Bitcoin's own adoption and future price. The name doesn't establish the equivalence.

## The Natural Experiment Has Been Run

We don't have to imagine Bitcoin as legal tender, because two countries tried it.

El Salvador made Bitcoin legal tender in 2021, with the state behind it, a government wallet and a legal duty on merchants to accept it. If any setting could turn it into everyday money, this was it. So what happened? Researchers Fernando Alvarez, David Argente and Diana Van Patten studied the result using a nationally representative face-to-face survey of households together with data on wallet transactions. Their paper, later published in *Science*, found that usage was "low, concentrated, and has been decreasing over time". In early 2025, under a USD 1.4 billion agreement with the IMF, El Salvador amended the law so that merchants no longer have to accept Bitcoin.

The Central African Republic adopted it in April 2022, against the objections of its regional central bank. Its parliament voted to repeal the law in March 2023.

I don't want to overclaim this. IMF pressure and regional treaty obligations were real factors, and neither country is a clean laboratory. But a common reply is that monetary use just needs time and legal recognition, and here it got legal recognition and people still preferred what they already had.

Adoption is the fact Bitcoin's monetary case most needs and has least of. How many employees negotiate wages without reference to another unit? How many farmers budget in BTC, and how many businesses keep their main accounts in it? Compared with national currencies, very few.

## Gharar, Maysir and Where I Stop Short

The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ forbade the sale determined by throwing pebbles and the sale involving *gharar*, prohibited uncertainty (Sahih Muslim 1513, narrated by Abu Hurairah).

That text needs careful handling. Gharar doesn't mean every uncertain outcome. A merchant can't guarantee profit, a farmer can't guarantee rain, and Islamic trade permits commercial risk. A legitimately owned commodity with a changing market price isn't made unlawful by the change. If a seller owns Bitcoin and hands over valid control at once, I can't honestly claim that price volatility alone voids that one spot sale.

My question is wider. Can an instrument subject to extreme speculative revaluation give the certainty that a monetary system owes the people who must use it? When it's a voluntary trade, the risk belongs to the trader. When it's money, the risk lands on everyone paid in it.

Here I am not alone. In November 2021 the Fatwa Commission of Majelis Ulama Indonesia ruled the use of cryptocurrency as currency haram, citing *gharar*, *dharar* (harm) and conflict with Indonesian monetary law. Dharar has a textual home in the narration "There should be neither harming nor reciprocating harm" (Sunan Ibn Majah 2340), though scholars differ on grading that chain, with al-Albani accepting it as sahih and Zubair Ali Zai treating it as weak. On trading, the Commission added *qimar*, gambling, and held crypto invalid as a commodity for sale unless it meets the conditions of *sil'ah*, has an underlying asset, and is free of gharar, dharar and qimar.

Muhammadiyah's path is instructive. Its Tarjih council ruled cryptocurrency haram both as investment and as a medium of exchange in 2022, then in March 2026 conditionally accepted crypto assets as recognised property that can be traded. It didn't move on money. It still rejects crypto as currency, and a council member explained in July 2026 that volatility matters mainly when crypto is used as money, a problem he said Bitcoin shares despite being among the more stable. The East Java branch of Nahdlatul Ulama has moved too: it treated Bitcoin as virtual property in 2018, then ruled cryptocurrency haram in 2021.

Other rulings point the other way on trading. In July 2020 the Shariah Advisory Council of Malaysia's Securities Commission permitted trading digital assets on registered exchanges. Read the resolution closely. It treats a digital currency with no underlying asset as *'urudh*, goods, and states that it is not a currency from a Shariah perspective. So on monetary identity, the council agrees with this article. The difference comes next.

So the trading question is open, and qualified bodies have ruled differently on it. They do share a method I don't follow: these rulings mostly address cryptocurrency as a class. I don't classify all crypto into a single category, which is why each instrument here gets its own analysis and its own verdict. My Bitcoin conclusion sits closer to MUI's, for reasons that include matters summaries of these rulings don't appear to weigh: recoverability and energy. My Ether and XRP conclusions are narrower. They concern currency.

Speculation raises the *maysir* question too, since Al-Ma'idah 5:90 names gambling among what the believer must avoid, though I don't claim every purchase made in hope of a higher price is gambling, because Islam permits investment. Leveraged bets and derivatives that amount to wagers on price movements are a different matter and raise the concern directly. Ownership is judged separately. Yet if someone buys mainly because they expect the next buyer to pay more, what economic purpose has been served? When that motive sits at the centre of an instrument's identity, it counts against calling that instrument money.

## Bitcoin's Second Failure: Rights Nobody Can Exercise

Someone earns Bitcoin lawfully over twenty years. They keep records, pay what they owe, and leave a family with a clear legal claim. Then they die, and nobody has the keys.

The ledger still shows the balance. The heirs may even identify it, and a court may confirm their entitlement, but none of that moves a single unit, because the protocol recognises a valid signature and nothing else. The ledger has preserved an accurate record of wealth that nobody can use.

Bitcoin's own security guidance says as much: coins "can be lost forever if you don't have a backup plan". Nor is this rare. Chainalysis estimated in 2017 that between about 2.8 and 3.8 million bitcoin, 17% to 23% of the supply at that time, had been lost. The higher figure relies on assumptions, including Satoshi Nakamoto's dormant holdings, and dormancy doesn't prove loss, so treat it as an estimate. Even the low end is a staggering amount of property with no one able to reach it.

Why does this matter religiously? Because the Qur'an gives heirs "an obligatory share" of what the deceased leaves, "be it little or much" (An-Nisa 4:7). It calls property "a means of sustenance" and tells us not to hand it to those unable to manage it (An-Nisa 4:5). The preservation of wealth, *hifz al-mal*, is one of the five necessities al-Ghazali named in *al-Mustasfa*. None mentions wallets, naturally. But they treat property as something that must reach the person entitled to it, not as a record.

Cash burns and gold gets buried, I know, and no system eliminates loss. What differs is this: when a bank depositor dies, a lawful procedure exists; with base-layer Bitcoin, once every authorisation path is gone, none does. Multisignature wallets, custodians and inheritance services reduce the risk, and they're worth using. They are also precautions a person has to take in advance, and custodians quietly bring back the intermediaries Bitcoin was built to remove.

Here the fiqh is least settled. Key loss doesn't automatically create gharar in the original sale, and I won't misrepresent it as a contractual defect. A competent jurist could press me here, and I could be wrong about how much weight it bears in a formal ruling. I'm making a claim about monetary architecture: a feature can fail the test of Islamic economic soundness while its exact relation to a classical prohibition still needs scholarly work.

For a speculative holding, some people may knowingly accept that risk. For the money a society runs on, I don't accept it.

## Bitcoin's Third Failure: The Bill That Never Ends

Gold is mined once. After that it doesn't need miners to keep being gold.

Bitcoin's arrangement is different, and people miss this. Its supply stops growing, but under the current consensus rules the computation doesn't stop, because that competition is what secures the ledger. When block subsidies eventually end, transaction fees have to pay for it instead. How much electricity that will take is unknowable today, since it depends on revenue, hardware and power prices. The structural requirement remains.

The Cambridge Digital Mining Industry Report estimated annualised consumption at about 138 terawatt-hours as of June 2024, roughly 0.5% of global electricity. Cambridge's preliminary update, as reported, puts the figure near 190 terawatt-hours by December 2025.

The best reply is the energy mix, and it deserves a fair statement. Cambridge's 2025 report found 52.4% of miners' electricity came from sustainable sources, and later figures are reported to be higher. Some miners also use power that might otherwise go unused. Good. That partly answers a climate objection, which was never my objection. Mine is about opportunity cost. A clean kilowatt-hour can also run a clinic, a cold store or an irrigation pump, wherever the grid can reach them, and where mining adds demand to a constrained grid, others may pay more for power.

Private profitability is not proof of social productivity. A miner paying its bills tells you what miners can earn, not what society got.

The Qur'an says Allah "likes not those who commit excess" (Al-A'raf 7:31), a verse about food and drink, so extending it to energy is my reasoning, and that "the wasteful are brothers of the devils" (Al-Isra 17:26-27). I'm not arguing that all electricity use is waste, or that security should be free. *Isrāf* is about proportion, and I'm arguing that spending has to be proportionate to demonstrable benefit.

Ethereum raises the stakes. When it moved off Proof of Work in September 2022, its annualised electricity use fell by more than 99.988%, according to the Crypto Carbon Ratings Institute estimate that ethereum.org reports. Different consensus models carry different security and trust assumptions, and Bitcoin's advocates may well have a case that theirs is stronger. Let them make that case. Saying Bitcoin can't work under its present rules without mining merely describes the design.

## So What Is Bitcoin?

You can't eat it or solder with it, so it isn't a commodity in the way gold or wheat is, and though it has been used for payments, that doesn't decide its identity. My classification is this: Bitcoin is a speculative digital asset with commodity-like market behaviour and limited monetary use. The verdict rests on that.

## My Position on Bitcoin

Its supply is predictable, its ledger works, its transfers can be verified, and it moves across borders. Those are genuine merits, and they don't touch the foundations, because the purchasing power has fallen by more than 90% once and more than 50% on other occasions. The prevailing economic identity is speculative. Legal tender status didn't produce everyday monetary use. There's no general recovery when every key is lost, and the security model carries a continuing cost it hasn't justified.

**I do not consider Bitcoin a halal product or a halal monetary medium under its present architecture and prevailing economic use.**

Now the edges. It's my personal economic and Islamic ethical judgment. I don't claim that each deficiency renders every Bitcoin transaction void under every school of jurisprudence. Part I also held that failing as currency doesn't by itself make something unlawful as property. I still hold that. My verdict rests on the cumulative case: an instrument offered as money, and held mostly for speculation, that fails on measure, preservation of rights and proportionate use of resources. I wouldn't recommend it to a Muslim as money or as a halal product.

It covers Bitcoin as it exists in October 2026 and its course over the foreseeable future, and should real improvements arrive in recoverability, stability, resource use and monetary adoption, I'd have to look again. I've shown why Bitcoin should not be considered halal. A counterargument now has to show clearly why it should be, whether as a currency or as a commodity.

## Ether: A Useful Platform Is Not a Currency

Ethereum is a programmable blockchain. Ether is the asset used to pay its fees and to secure its Proof-of-Stake consensus. Those are real uses, which is the strongest thing Ether has going for it. They are also the reason it doesn't count as money: a token required to use a service can have a market value without being a measure for anyone's wages.

If a merchant prices goods in dollars and pays network fees in ETH, the books are still in dollars. ETH is closer to a toll.

Origination comes first under the test, and here it's very different from Bitcoin, since Ethereum went live in 2015 with about 72 million ETH. The 2014 crowdsale sold around 60 million, and further allocations went to early contributors and a long-term reserve. That may fund software reasonably. Funding a project is one thing, though, and establishing a just distribution of general monetary purchasing power is another. Who received those units, and why should they have a head start in a would-be monetary order?

Ether does earn credit on resource use, as we've seen. Proof of Stake brings its own questions: who can afford to validate, what role large staking providers play, and whether large holdings translate into influence. Efficiency is a merit, not legitimacy.

Supply offers no rescue. Ether has no fixed ceiling, with validator rewards adding units and part of each fee being burned, so net supply moves with activity. Neither arrangement steadies its price, which remains exposed to the wider crypto market.

Is staking riba? Not automatically, and I won't say so. A validator performing a protocol-defined service for a reward isn't the same as a customer handing assets to an intermediary who promises a return, and the two need separate examination according to their actual terms. The same goes for applications. Ethereum hosts lawful exchange and settlement, and also interest-bearing lending, heavy leverage and gambling-like contracts. A smart contract isn't halal because it executes automatically, and one haram application doesn't condemn every use of ETH.

**I do not consider Ether to have established legitimacy as a halal general-purpose monetary medium under its present architecture and economic use.**

I'm not declaring every ownership or use of Ether impermissible. Paying network fees is separate. My finding concerns what Ether should be accepted as: a network asset, yes; the money people live on, no.

## XRP: Moving Value Is Not Measuring It

XRP makes the most direct payments case of the three, since its ledger settles quickly at low cost, needs no mining and offers a validator-based consensus. So let me grant what it does well before asking whether that makes it currency.

Consider a cross-border payment. A sender's dollars become XRP, the XRP moves, and a receiving intermediary turns it into euros. It worked. Yet the invoice was in dollars, the recipient wanted euros, and nobody measured anything in XRP, so a bridge can help people cross without becoming the place they live.

Origination is where XRP's case is weakest. All 100 billion units were created at the start, with the founders giving 80 billion to the company that became Ripple and keeping 20 billion. In 2017 the company placed 55 billion in escrow to make their release more predictable. Transaction fees destroy tiny amounts. Nothing here is hidden, and a development company may well have good reasons to hold tokens that fund its work.

One question remains. What justifies introducing that quantity of purchasing power into the hands of so few, when no equivalent goods were produced to bring it into being? The right to issue a token and the legitimacy of introducing it as general money are separate questions. Fixed supply doesn't answer it. Who holds the units, and when they reach the market, still matter to everyone else holding them.

XRP's price, too, remains driven by speculative demand, its use as a unit of account is limited, and its self-custody carries the same recovery problem.

**I do not consider XRP to have established legitimacy as a halal independent general-purpose monetary medium under its present architecture and economic use.**

Lawful settlement is another matter. I classify it as a payment and liquidity asset with speculative investment characteristics, and its settlement speed doesn't change what it is.

## The Fifteen Characteristics Compared

These are economic and architectural findings, not a numerical score, and as Part II said, no number establishes halal or haram.

| Characteristic | Bitcoin (BTC) | Ether (ETH) | XRP |
|---|---|---|---|
| **1. Medium of exchange** | Supports payments; limited commercial use, low even under legal tender | Network payments; some wider use | Payment and bridge-settlement functions |
| **2. Store of value** | Falls of about 94%, 78% and 54% | Substantial volatility | Substantial volatility |
| **3. Unit of account** | Limited independent pricing | Mainly network-specific | Mainly settlement; limited independent pricing |
| **4. Trust and credibility** | Public rules, long history; confidence market-dependent | Transparent protocol; governance and market risks | Validator framework; identifiable governance questions |
| **5. Scarcity and supply discipline** | About 21 million limit | Variable net supply from issuance and burning | Fixed original supply; circulating supply changes |
| **6. Universality and accessibility** | Global transfer; technical, financial and regulatory barriers | Broad participation; fee and technical barriers | International settlement, subject to infrastructure and liquidity |
| **7. Adaptability** | Conservative protocol evolution | Active development | Ledger amendments, validator governance |
| **8. Durability** | Persistent ledger | Persistent ledger | Persistent ledger |
| **9. Portability** | Digital and cross-border | Digital and cross-border | Digital and cross-border |
| **10. Divisibility** | Highly divisible | Highly divisible | Highly divisible |
| **11. Security** | Proof of Work; wallet and custody risks | Proof of Stake; smart-contract and custody risks | Validator consensus; governance and custody risks |
| **12. Recoverability** | No general recovery when all keys are lost | No universal base-layer recovery | No universal recovery after complete credential loss |
| **13. Freedom from interest-based architecture** | Issuance needs no interest-bearing loans; external lending may involve riba | Staking needs separate assessment; DeFi may involve prohibited terms | Issuance needs no interest-bearing lending; external contracts need assessment |
| **14. Preservation of wealth** | Volatility, speculation, permanent key loss | Volatility, contract and custody risks | Volatility, concentration and custody risks |
| **15. Resource efficiency** | Substantial continuing Proof-of-Work energy use | Major reduction after moving to Proof of Stake | No mining; comparatively low-energy consensus |

Notice how much of the technical column is strong. Durability, portability and divisibility mostly describe any digital ledger. It's on measure, value and rights that the three fall short, and those are the jobs money exists to do. Predictable supply isn't predictable purchasing power.

Origination sits outside the table because it comes first. Bitcoin issues through mining rewards, Ether through initial allocation and then protocol issuance, XRP entirely at genesis. A transparent mechanism tells you who received the units, not whether the allocation was just.

## The Verdicts, as of October 2026

| Instrument | My position | Principal grounds |
|---|---|---|
| **Bitcoin (BTC)** | **Not halal as a product or monetary medium under present conditions** | Speculative character, extreme volatility, no recoverability, limited independent monetary function, Proof-of-Work resource burden |
| **Ether (ETH)** | **Not halal as a general-purpose currency** | Network utility isn't monetary status; volatility, issuance, recovery and financial-use concerns |
| **XRP** | **Not halal as an independent general-purpose currency** | Settlement function isn't monetary legitimacy; origination, distribution, volatility and recovery concerns |

The Bitcoin judgment is broader, and deliberately so, because of Proof of Work and because Bitcoin's prevailing identity is the speculative one. The other two concern classification, and they aren't pronouncements on every lawful use of those assets.

Avoiding a fatwa isn't avoiding judgment. A researcher may examine evidence and judge, a reader may disagree, and a scholar may take the reasoning apart.

## If You Believe Bitcoin Is Halal

Then I'd like to read your answer, and I mean that. It would need to explain:

- how an instrument with falls of about 94%, 78% and 54% qualifies as a dependable measure;
- what establishes its independent unit of account, given what happened in El Salvador;
- how the rights of heirs are protected when lost keys can end access permanently;
- how the classical description of money as a measure, not a commodity traded for profit, can be reconciled with how Bitcoin is held;
- how the continuing expenditure of Proof of Work meets the prohibition of *isrāf*, in terms of benefit delivered.

Market capitalisation isn't an answer, and neither is popularity, scarcity alone, or the word decentralised, and if a fatwa permits Bitcoin, tell me whether it examined these questions, because a ruling that didn't can't settle them.

And if the evidence is better than mine, my conclusion should change. I'm committed to one standard, not to a permanent negative.

## The Same Test Comes for Everyone

Innovation isn't prohibited. Bitcoin showed that strangers can agree on a ledger without a bank, Ethereum showed what programmable infrastructure can do, and XRP showed another approach to settlement. Those are achievements, and they answer a different question from the one this series is asking.

Lawful exchange, protection of wealth, avoidance of prohibited uncertainty and responsible use of resources have to be applied without favourites. That means the dollar, and stablecoins, face the same questions next. So does GX Protocol. The criteria don't change with the name on the instrument, and they don't change with the name of whoever built it.

A monetary system doesn't become legitimate because its supporters believe in it. It has to survive questions about its origin, its function and its costs, and about what happens to a family when the person holding the keys is gone.

---

*Next in this series: [Part IV: USDT, USDC and the US Dollar: When Digital Money Becomes a Claim on Fiat](/blog/usdt-usdc-and-the-us-dollar)*

*This article presents an economic and jurisprudential argument for scholarly examination, not a fatwa, and its proposed criteria are subject to further evaluation against the Qur'an, Sunnah, established jurisprudence, and verifiable economic evidence.*

## References

**Qur'an** (Sahih International translation)

- 2:188; 4:5; 4:7; 4:29; 5:90; 7:31; 17:26-27; 17:35.

**Hadith** (references follow [sunnah.com](https://sunnah.com) numbering)

- Sahih Muslim 1513, Abu Hurairah: the sale of pebbles and the sale of gharar.
- Sunan Ibn Majah 2340, Ubadah ibn al-Samit: no harming nor reciprocating harm. Grading differs among scholars, as noted in the text.

**Classical sources** (see [The Architecture Akhtar Is Asking For](/blog/the-architecture-akhtar-is-asking-for) for fuller quotation)

- Al-Ghazali, *Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din*, Kitab al-Shukr; *al-Mustasfa min 'Ilm al-Usul*.
- Ibn Taymiyyah, *Majmu' al-Fatawa*, vols. 19 and 29.
- Ibn al-Qayyim, *I'lam al-Muwaqqi'in*, vol. 2; see A. A. Islahi, ["Economic thought of Ibn al-Qayyim"](https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/41369/1/economic_thought_of_ibn_al-qayyim.pdf).

**Contemporary rulings**

- Majelis Ulama Indonesia, [decision of the Ijtima Ulama of the Fatwa Commission VII](https://fatwamui.com/storage/614/HUKUM-CRYPTOCURRENCY.pdf), 9-11 November 2021.
- Muhammadiyah, Majelis Tarjih dan Tajdid, [fatwa on crypto as a digital financial asset](https://muhammadiyah.or.id/2026/03/fatwa-majelis-tarjih-dan-tajdid-pp-muhammadiyah-tentang-kripto-sebagai-aset-keuangan-digital/), March 2026; [statement on crypto as currency](https://muhammadiyah.or.id/2026/07/muhammadiyah-tegaskan-kripto-tidak-sah-sebagai-mata-uang-blockchain-tetap-berpotensi-wujudkan-kemaslahatan/), July 2026; 2022 fatwa as reported by [Fortune IDN](https://www.fortuneidn.com/sharia/desy/muhammadiyah-kripto-haram-sebagai-investasi-dan-alat-tukar).
- Nahdlatul Ulama, East Java: [Bitcoin ruling, Tuban 2018](https://islam.nu.or.id/bahtsul-masail/hukum-transaksi-dengan-bitcoin-1sQB9); [cryptocurrency ruling, 2021](https://jatim.nu.or.id/metropolis/bahtsul-masail-nu-jatim-putuskan-cryptocurrency-haram-yvs6f).
- Shariah Advisory Council, Securities Commission Malaysia, resolution on digital assets, announced July 2020, as reported by [The Edge Malaysia](https://theedgemalaysia.com/article/sc-shariah-advisory-council-permits-trading-digital-assets-says-chairman) and summarised at [Capital Markets Malaysia](https://www.capitalmarketsmalaysia.com/digital-digital-asset-exchange/).

**Bitcoin, legal tender, Ethereum and XRP**

- Satoshi Nakamoto, [*Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System*](https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf), 2008.
- Bitcoin.org, ["Securing your wallet"](https://bitcoin.org/en/secure-your-wallet).
- Price history: [Bitcoin Magazine](https://bitcoinmagazine.com/markets/bitcoin-price-breaks-all-time-high) on the June 2011 Mt Gox high; [BitMEX Research](https://www.bitmex.com/blog/the-june-2011-bitcoin-flash-crash) on the June 2011 hack; [Euronews](https://www.euronews.com/2022/11/22/bitcoin-plunges-to-a-2-year-low-as-ftx-collapse-contaminates-industry) on November 2022; [IG](https://www.ig.com/uk/trading-strategies/bitcoin-price-recovery-has-it-bottomed-260731) on the October 2025 high and June 2026 low.
- Chainalysis estimate of lost bitcoin, 2017, as reported by [Fortune](https://fortune.com/crypto/2017/11/25/lost-bitcoins).
- Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, [*Cambridge Digital Mining Industry Report*](https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/faculty-research/centres/alternative-finance/publications/cambridge-digital-mining-industry-report/), 2025; [summary](https://jbs.cam.ac.uk/2025/cambridge-study-sustainable-energy-rising-in-bitcoin-mining/); December 2025 update as reported by [KuCoin News](https://www.kucoin.com/news/flash/bitcoin-mining-power-surges-to-190-twh-emissions-rise-despite-cleaner-energy-mix).

- Fernando Alvarez, David Argente and Diana Van Patten, ["Are Cryptocurrencies Currencies? Bitcoin as Legal Tender in El Salvador"](https://www.nber.org/papers/w29968), NBER Working Paper 29968, 2022; later published in *Science*, vol. 382, 2023.
- [Decrypt](https://decrypt.co/303626?amp=1) and [Electronic Payments International](https://www.electronicpaymentsinternational.com/news/el-salvador-amends-bitcoin-law-imf) on El Salvador's 2025 amendment.
- [Central Banking](https://www.centralbanking.com/central-banks/currency/digital-currencies/7956294/car-to-drop-crypto-as-legal-tender) on the Central African Republic.

- Ethereum.org, ["Ethereum's energy consumption"](https://ethereum.org/en/energy-consumption/); [Ethereum whitepaper](https://ethereum.org/en/whitepaper/), currency issuance.
- XRP Ledger documentation, ["What is XRP?"](https://xrpl.org/docs/introduction/what-is-xrp).
