Part I of V. The Currency Question: Money, Commodities, and the Architecture of Islamic Economics

The Question We Skipped

Is Bitcoin halal? Is Ethereum, or USDT, or XRP, and how would anyone trying to do right by their savings know the difference?

Scholars have permitted these assets and scholars have prohibited them. Some separate cryptocurrencies from tokens, or speculation from commerce, while others ask whether society recognises the asset as valuable property (māl) or examine the uncertainty (gharar), gambling (maysir) and interest (riba) around its markets. The debate continues.

It will keep continuing, because we're trying to decide whether a particular form of money is permissible without first agreeing on what counts as money.

Look at the candidates. We accept the US dollar as money, even though it can be traded, speculated on, lent and created through an interest-based banking system. We call gold a commodity, although it served as money for thousands of years. We call Bitcoin a cryptocurrency, although much of its activity is buying it, holding it and selling it for other currencies. Then we ask a scholar to rule.

Something is missing. A definition.

I don't mean one invented to defend a favourite coin, a government's currency or a new monetary protocol, but foundational criteria applied equally to every candidate. The dollar faces the same questions as Bitcoin, gold gets no exemption for being ancient, and a digital system gets no rejection for being new.

A criterion that changes according to the instrument being examined is not a criterion. It is a preference.

Six Items in a Hadith

The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said, as narrated by Ubadah ibn al-Samit:

"Gold is to be paid for by gold, silver by silver, wheat by wheat, barley by barley, dates by dates, and salt by salt, like for like and equal for equal, payment being made hand to hand. If these classes differ, then sell as you wish if payment is made hand to hand." (Sahih Muslim 1587c)

Two precious metals, two grains, a fruit, a mineral. They differ in how they're produced, how abundant they are, how well they divide and how long they last, yet they appear together in a single ruling on exchange.

Precision matters here.

The hadith does not declare that wheat, barley, dates and salt are currencies in the sense that gold and silver historically were. It sets rules for exchanging six specified commodities, commonly called the six ribawi items, because particular exchanges involving them can give rise to riba. The jurists went looking for the underlying legal cause, the illah. They disagreed. For gold and silver, attention fell on monetary function, weight and the nature of the metals, while the schools weighed edibility, measurability and storability differently for the four foods.

So be careful in both directions. Declare all six to be currencies and you've introduced a proposition the hadith doesn't state. Dismiss the four foods and you miss what the ruling does show: Islamic commercial law regulates exchange according to the characteristics and relationships of the things exchanged, not merely their names or the willingness of two parties to trade them.

That doesn't prove what a currency must be. It does demand that we examine what an economic instrument actually is before we settle the rules that govern it.

The First Question: What Is a Commodity?

Start with wheat. A farmer prepares the land, plants, irrigates, harvests and brings the produce to market, spending natural resources, capital, knowledge, time and risk along the way. The result can be eaten, milled, stored or sold.

Gold doesn't grow in a field. It has to be found, mined, separated and refined before anyone can use it in jewellery, electronics, reserves or exchange, and its long history as money doesn't erase the fact that it's an economic product.

A commodity, then, is a good with market value that can be produced, owned, used or exchanged, and it has an economic identity independent of its use in exchange. Gold remains gold whether or not someone accepts it in payment. Wheat stays wheat.

Which gives us the distinction that has to guide everything about Bitcoin: something can be valuable, exchangeable and widely traded without being a currency.

Being Used in Exchange Is Not Being Money

Imagine a farmer with 100 kilograms of wheat who offers 20 of them to a carpenter for a table. The carpenter agrees. Elsewhere a fisherman swaps fish for a sack of salt and a mining company trades gold for equipment.

Are wheat, fish and gold now currencies? Not necessarily. Economists call those transactions barter, and a medium of exchange is something narrower: it is accepted not mainly for direct use, but because it can later be passed on to obtain other things. If I take wheat to eat it, that's barter. If I take wheat with no need to eat it, because I know others will accept it from me later, wheat has begun to perform a monetary function.

One transaction doesn't make a monetary system. A society that routinely settles in a particular instrument starts to develop one.

We need four separate concepts here:

  • Commodity: an economic good or asset that has value and can be traded.
  • Medium of exchange: an instrument accepted as an intermediary through which goods and services are exchanged.
  • Money: a socially or institutionally recognised mechanism for measuring value, transferring purchasing power and settling obligations, commonly serving as medium of exchange, unit of account and store of value.
  • Currency: a particular standardised monetary instrument or unit through which those functions are organised within an economy.

Everyday speech blurs money and currency, and that's fine until you need to separate the broader institution from the specific instrument. Three things follow once you do. An item can be both a commodity and money, as gold shows. It can be money without being a commodity, as modern fiat currency shows, and it can be a digitally transferable asset without having established itself as a functioning currency.

That last one is Bitcoin's question.

Gold: A Commodity That Also Became Money

Gold is awkward for anyone who likes simple definitions. Today it's quoted in dollars, traded on commodity markets, held by central banks and chased by speculators, yet historically it was money. Was it a currency then and not now?

It depends what we're examining. Gold has the physical characteristics of a commodity however it's used, but monetary status is relational: when gold is commonly accepted to settle obligations and express prices, it performs the role of money, and when it's mostly bought as jewellery or held as an investment, those other roles come forward.

The substance hasn't changed. Its economic role has.

So classification can't rest on what an instrument is made of, and even function isn't enough. We also have to ask how it's created, who controls its issuance, what establishes its value and what obligations come with owning it. A gold coin and a paper certificate representing a claim on gold do not share an architecture. One is the asset. The other is a representation of the asset, standing on a contractual promise, and any serious evaluation of money has to start from that difference.

The Second Question: How Does Money Come Into Existence?

Wheat arrives through cultivation and gold through extraction. A bank deposit arrives differently.

When a commercial bank grants a loan, it will commonly create a matching deposit in the borrower's account, so that a financial asset appears on the bank's balance sheet alongside a new liability. The deposit circulates as purchasing power. The debt stays with the borrower.

Some care is needed here, because bank-created deposits differ from physical currency and central-bank reserves, and not every dollar comes into existence through an individual interest-bearing loan. The broader questions stand anyway. What does it mean for transferable purchasing power to be created through a credit relationship, and does that sit comfortably with the principles of an Islamic economy, when money creation is so closely tied to interest-bearing financing?

Wide acceptance settles none of this. The questions concern the architecture of monetary creation.

The Same Question, Applied to Bitcoin

Bitcoin comes from neither a harvest, nor a mine in the ground, nor a bank's balance sheet, because its issuance follows a predetermined protocol through which miners compete to add blocks to the ledger.

Here the trouble starts. That computation gets presented as productive economic activity. Showing that something takes effort, electricity, equipment, capital and time doesn't establish that, because an economic system also has to be judged by the usefulness of its output and by what else its resources could have done. Proof-of-Work doesn't directly produce food, clothing, housing, education, medical care or manufactured goods. Its primary output is the continued operation and security of the Bitcoin network.

Nor is this temporary. Once the final Bitcoin is issued, the network will still need miners to run Proof-of-Work, provided its consensus architecture stays as it is, with transaction fees replacing the vanished block subsidy. So the question reaches past Bitcoin's creation, to the ongoing cost of keeping it running.

What the Electricity Could Have Done

Electricity is more than an accounting expense. Farms use it for irrigation and refrigeration, factories for production lines, hospitals for essential equipment, and schools and households depend on it being reliable and affordable. Every large allocation of energy therefore carries an economic question.

What else could it have served?

That is opportunity cost. Electricity consumed by mining isn't available for other purposes, unless the wider system can add capacity without displacing existing demand. Where mining adds demand to a market with limited generation or transmission, it may push prices up, and a farmer or a manufacturer who pays more will pass some of it into the prices of what they sell.

I don't claim every mining facility raises electricity prices, or that every unit it consumes could immediately go elsewhere. Actual effects depend on local supply, transmission constraints, generation costs and spare capacity. This is the part of the argument I'm least able to settle from a desk, and I could be wrong about how large the effect is in any given market.

The issue survives those qualifications. A monetary instrument that needs substantial recurring energy has to justify it against what those resources could otherwise do, the more so when other ways of securing digital transactions use vastly less computational energy. Why spend scarce productive resources on an energy-intensive architecture if comparable functions can be achieved far more efficiently?

This is an Islamic question too. The Qur'an condemns wastefulness and extravagance: Al-A'raf 7:31 instructs us not to be excessive, and Al-Isra 17:26–27 condemns wasteful expenditure. The principle of isrāf requires us to ask whether scarce resources are being consumed unnecessarily or disproportionately, and no technical system earns an exemption by being decentralised, profitable or popular.

An expensive security mechanism may well secure its network. Granted. That doesn't make it a responsible allocation of resources.

The economic cost of money is not limited to what its users pay, because it also includes the resources society must continuously devote to making that money function.

That principle belongs in our framework. It applies to Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP, stablecoins and fiat currency alike.

Is Bitcoin a Currency Because It Can Be Used to Pay?

Suppose someone buys Bitcoin with US dollars, holds it for six months and sells it at a profit. What was its function? An investment or trading asset, which bought no food, paid no wages and settled no invoice.

Now suppose a customer buys a computer directly with Bitcoin, and the merchant accepts and keeps it, in which case Bitcoin has acted as a medium of exchange. One purchase proves little. The harder questions are whether merchants independently price goods in Bitcoin, whether wages and obligations are routinely denominated in it, whether the unit is reliable enough for economic calculation, and whether people mostly acquire it for commerce or for anticipated appreciation.

Take a merchant who advertises that computer at USD 1,000 and converts the amount into Bitcoin at the moment of payment. That merchant is still using the dollar as the unit of account. Bitcoin may be the settlement instrument, a genuine monetary function, but a payment mechanism isn't necessarily the unit in which value is measured.

The opposite error comes easily. Being quoted in dollars doesn't prove Bitcoin can't be money, since foreign currencies are quoted against each other all day and gold's dollar price doesn't erase its monetary history. The stronger argument is simpler. Calling Bitcoin a mature general-purpose currency would require showing it performs the full set of monetary functions, at sufficient scale and with sufficient consistency.

I would therefore describe Bitcoin, in its prevailing economic use, as a scarce digital asset with transferable settlement capability and substantial speculative-commodity characteristics.

That's economics, not a ruling. The classification separates having a function from fulfilling the broader requirements of a currency.

The Third Question: Does Acceptance Create Legitimacy?

Some Islamic scholars and economists argue that money gets its status through social acceptance. The argument has a real basis, since people have to be willing to take an instrument if it is to circulate, and Islamic jurisprudence recognises established custom, ʿurf, within appropriate limits.

But how does the first unit become accepted? A merchant accepts money because others will, and others accept it because merchants do, and network effects, legal institutions and coordinated adoption can produce genuine acceptance out of that loop. Fine.

Acceptance still can't be the complete ethical criterion. A society can widely accept an arrangement that contains injustice, and a currency may dominate through historical, political, military or institutional circumstance, or because the state requires it for settling obligations. Acceptance tells us whether an instrument works. It doesn't prove that its creation, distribution or governance is just.

Two questions are tangled together here. The descriptive one asks whether society actually uses this instrument as money, and the normative one asks whether the system satisfies the principles of justice an Islamic economy should uphold.

Neither replaces the other. A currency may be economically successful and ethically defective, and an ethically ambitious system may be carefully designed and never get accepted at all.

The Fourth Question: What Does the Hadith Teach About Monetary Justice?

Return to the six commodities. When two items of the same specified kind are exchanged, equality and immediate possession matter, and when the categories differ, other rules apply depending on the relationship between the items and the legal cause the jurists identified. The aim goes beyond listing goods that were historically valuable. It is to prevent prohibited forms of increase and exchange.

In my previous writings I have argued that we must examine riba, dayn, qard, bay', gharar and maysir at the architectural level of the monetary system. They do different legal work. Riba concerns prohibited increases, dayn concerns debt or outstanding obligations, qard concerns lending and bay' concerns exchange and sale, while gharar concerns prohibited excessive uncertainty and maysir concerns gambling. Not every price swing is gharar, and not every profitable speculative trade is maysir.

The architectural question remains. Can a monetary system be structured so that prohibited lending arrangements, arbitrary issuance, opaque ownership, exploitative transfers of wealth and avoidable waste are systematically constrained?

This is where monetary design becomes an Islamic economic question. Not because a software developer can replace a scholar, or because a blockchain can declare a transaction halal, but because the rules governing issuance, transfer, ownership, settlement and resource consumption can materially affect whether economic relationships conform to Islamic principles.

The Fifth Question: What Must a Currency Possess?

Fourteen characteristics make a useful starting point: medium-of-exchange functionality, store of value, unit of account, trust and credibility, scarcity, universality, adaptability, durability, portability, divisibility, security, recoverability, freedom from interest-based arrangements, and preservation of wealth. To these I would add a fifteenth, resource efficiency and economic responsibility, because a monetary system should be judged by how much scarce resource it takes to create, maintain and operate as well as by how well it moves value.

They aren't all mandatory. A currency that slowly loses purchasing power doesn't stop being a currency, and a payment instrument can be highly portable and still never become an independent unit of account. Nor is scarcity proof of soundness. So I'd separate three levels of examination.

Monetary identity. Does the instrument function as money, with an identifiable unit that can be transferred and can settle obligations, accepted beyond isolated transactions, operating as a medium of exchange and unit of account?

Monetary quality. How well does it function? Does it preserve purchasing power, is it durable, divisible, portable, secure, recoverable and accessible, are its issuance rules transparent, and does its operation create unnecessary burdens for others in society?

Monetary justice. How is it created? Who receives new units, does issuance create contractual indebtedness, does the architecture facilitate or prohibit riba, are ownership and settlement rights clear, and does it enable arbitrary confiscation, unequal privileges, deception, unjust enrichment or wasteful consumption of resources?

Then we can compare. Otherwise a technically excellent payment network gets mistaken for an excellent currency, and a historically established currency gets its acceptance mistaken for a justification of its architecture.

From Creation to Circulation

Most discussions of money begin after the instrument already exists: how fast it moves, what a transfer costs, whether it can be divided, stored or exchanged. Necessary questions. Nowhere near sufficient.

A monetary system has a whole lifecycle, and rights and obligations arise at each stage. Who receives the first unit, by what right, and what do they give for it? Who can issue more? Does someone become indebted when a unit is created, can existing holders be diluted, what happens to lost units, and can they be inherited? Can the issuer change the rules after distribution, or move wealth from one group to another without their meaningful consent, and what recurring burden must society carry to keep the thing running?

None of that is administrative detail.

A currency that's efficient in payment but unjust in creation hasn't been adequately evaluated, and neither has one with transparent issuance and uncertain ownership rights. A currency that prevents interest at the protocol level, while letting institutions build interest-bearing obligations around it, hasn't eliminated every form of riba associated with its use. The same scrutiny extends to physical commodities, sovereign issuance, commercial banking and distributed ledgers.

Cryptocurrency Is Not One Thing

We say "cryptocurrency" as though it names one economic instrument. It doesn't. Bitcoin is issued through proof-of-work mining on a predetermined schedule, while Ether pays execution fees on Ethereum and participates in a proof-of-stake system. XRP runs on a different ledger architecture and supply model. USDT and USDC are privately issued tokens designed to track the dollar, supported by reserve arrangements.

Their issuance, purposes, distribution histories, links to debt, exposure to speculation and resource requirements all differ, so a single universal classification makes little analytical sense. The same goes for "the US dollar", which can mean physical notes, commercial bank deposits, central-bank money or the broader dollar credit system.

So the word names a family. It doesn't tell us whether the instrument is sound money, and it certainly doesn't establish whether it is halal or haram.

Halal and Haram Come Later

Islamic jurisprudence has developed sophisticated principles on ownership, exchange, lending, debt, uncertainty and prohibited enrichment, and they deserve better than a quick application to whatever financial technology is attracting attention this year.

Reversing the argument is dangerous too. I want to be plain about it, because it could be turned against this very series. We can't create a new economic definition of currency, declare it a mandatory Islamic requirement, and then conclude that everything failing it is haram. That would be overreach.

An asset may fail to qualify as currency and still be legitimate property. A currency may be imperfect and still be legally recognised as money, and a wasteful arrangement may raise a serious ethical objection without rendering every unit associated with it prohibited. A transaction may be prohibited even when the currency used in it is perfectly legitimate.

Those distinctions keep us from turning economic judgments into religious rulings without sufficient evidence. The proper sequence runs like this:

  1. Identify the instrument.
  2. Establish how it is created, owned, transferred, valued and used.
  3. Determine whether it qualifies as money, a commodity, a claim or another form of property.
  4. Assess its monetary quality and underlying economic architecture, including its resource requirements and wider consequences.
  5. Apply the relevant principles of Islamic jurisprudence to the instrument and the transactions involving it.

Only then is there a foundation for a responsible judgment on permissibility, and that judgment has to remain open to scholarly examination, disagreement and correction.

Where the Investigation Begins

Before asking whether Bitcoin is halal, I would ask whether it satisfies the criteria of a currency. Before accepting USDT or USDC as digital dollars, I would examine the contractual claims, reserves and issuance mechanisms behind them, and before assuming the dollar is sound money, I would look at its creation, distribution and purchasing power.

Nothing here rejects what exists. It is meant to stop us confusing familiarity with legitimacy, popularity with suitability, and technology with economic justice.

The six commodities mentioned by the Prophet ﷺ remind us that exchange is governed by principles, not merely by what people agree to call the things being exchanged. Our challenge is to apply that discipline to instruments that could not have existed in their present technological form fourteen centuries ago, with criteria that can be published, examined, challenged and consistently applied across gold, wheat, sovereign currency, bank deposits, Bitcoin, stablecoins and newly designed protocols. We also need humility. Revelation expressly establishes some things, and human reasoning reaches the rest.

Before we ask whether a cryptocurrency is halal, we must establish what it is. Before we conclude that a monetary system conforms to Islamic principles, we must examine all of it, from the creation of the first unit to the settlement of the final transaction.

That is where the investigation begins.


Next in this series: Part II, The Currency Litmus Test: Fifteen Characteristics and the Architecture of Money.

This article presents an economic and jurisprudential argument for scholarly examination, not a fatwa, and its proposed criteria are subject to further evaluation against the Qur'an, Sunnah, established jurisprudence, and verifiable economic evidence.